⚡ How To Use Substack To Grow a Non-Substack Newsletter


​[Read the browser version right here]​


Hey Reader!

Here's what's happening in this edition:

→ How To Grow a Non-Substack Newsletter on Substack
→ *NEW* Resource of the week
→ 5 Growth Levers Every Successful Newsletter Has
→ The Landing Page Headline that 5x'd Conversions
→ Newsletter Growth Channels as Ranked by Matt McGarry
→ Pics from my trip to Lisbon
→ and more!

Dive in ↓

Resource Of The Week ⚡

(This is a new tool I'm testing out, and I think you might like it too!)

Get trivia quizzes built-in to your newsletter.

I don't know about you...

But I want people to do two things when I send them my newsletter:

1) Open it
2)
Learn something useful

I found a fun tool that can do both.

It's called Atrivial. And it lets you add a quiz to your newsletter based on your newsletter content — or anything you want!

I'm a sucker for games, quizzes, trivia -- anything that makes me more likely to open a newsletter.

So I had to try Atrivial in mine.

>> Go check out the quiz near the end of this newsletter <<

​Try Atrivial your newsletter today →​
(Use my affiliate link above for an extra 10% off!)

THE "OBVIOUS"
​SUBSTACK GROWTH STRATEGY

Or: How to Grow Your Non-Substack Newsletter with Substack

Back when I launched this newsletter on Substack in January 2021, the platform (and the world) was VERY different.

Back then, Substack was the perfect "turnkey" platform to start a newsletter. So that's what I did. I signed up and grew a newsletter to about 700 subscribers in ~9 months.

But along the way, I realized it was not the platform I needed.

So after 9 months I switched to Kit (aka ConvertKit circa 2021) where I could tag, run automations, welcome sequences, and build lead magnets.

MY BIG-ISH MISTAKE

But I made a big-ish mistake after I switched.

I kind of ignored Substack.

Fast-forward 5 years and Substack has been on a heater adding a features for content creators like podcasting, paywalls, recommendations, and loads of others.

But the most impactful feature might be what they launched in April 2023.That's when Substack Notes came on the scene: their version of a social media feed.

I remember that April heading over to see what the fuss was about, and then quickly turning around and peacing out.

It was Twitter with a facelift and not a lot happening.

But Substack has over 20 million monthly active users (source) and guess what?

Those users are prime newsletter readers for two key reasons:

  1. They're active on a text-first platform (newsletters are a text-based medium)
  2. They are familiar with — and apt to — subscribe to newsletters

My newsletter friend, these. are. our. people!

So, after you go through the steps below, I would *highly* recommend getting active on Substack Notes. I'm not recommending new content on a new platform.

Just repurpose your content from your main platform.

I simply take my LinkedIn content and publish it there.

The great thing about Substack Notes is that there is a big ol' "Subscribe" button everywhere. It's the only social platform that's essentially got a one-click subscribe in the feed.

Take advantage 👇

HOW I USE SUBSTACK TO
​
GROW MY KIT NEWSLETTER

I haven't sent a "regular" edition of my newsletter through Substack since 2021.

But I still get subscribers signing up for my Substack newsletter regularly. Now, to be fair... it's not a lot of subscribers. Maybe a handful per week. But it's enough to have a process around it.

Plus, if you've been following Chenell's Growth In Public story, it's pretty telling that Substack is "winning" when it comes to organic growth.

So here's how it works.

HOW TO DO IT

(It's pretty simple. This setup shouldn't take more than 20-30 mins)

​READ THE WHOLE ARTICLE >>​

(Had to move the rest of this article to my website b/c of Gmail clipping -- sorry!)

Newsletter Hits Of The Week ⚡

Curated links I found just for you — with my two cents.
​

⚡ The 5 Growth Levers Behind Every Fast-Growing Newsletter →​
​According to Chenell Basilio, there are 5 key growth levers every newsletter needs to consider to actually grow their newsletter quickly and effectively. Bonus: use the Growth Levers Scorecard to find your biggest weakness — and how to improve it!

⚡ The GOATed Landing Page Headline — that improved conversions from 7% to 35% → ​
​Max drops the next headline format I am 100% A/B testing on my landing page at 24:58 of this interview. You're welcome 😁

⚡ How to Optimize Your LinkedIn Profile in 2026 (8x More Views) → ​
​Why does this matter? Because your bio should compel visitors to your newsletter sign-up page. So optimize it! Also -- Diandra Escobar is one LinkedIn voice I find myself listening to a lot lately. Her content is actionable and thorough 💯

⚡ 5 New Substack Features You Might Have Missed This Month →​
​The most interesting of these features is the new "Freewall". Finally.

⚡ Tier list: The BEST newsletter growth channels →​
​My hot take: the channel matters way less than what you do with that subscriber after you acquire them. But Matt also knows a lot more about newsletter growth than I do 🎓

The most-clicked link from our last edition 👇

⚡ Is LinkedIn cooked? (he got 250K impressions in a week) →​

Big fan of Brandon Smithwrick and his Content To Commas newsletter. He's got some sage advice on what's working (or not) on LinkedIn.

Test Your Newsletter Knowledge

This quiz is brought to you by Atrivial*.

In my last newsletter edition — The Case For Unhinged Newsletters — I showed you how the Jay's Scoop newsletter caught my attention, and why that matters.

Do you remember?

Take the quiz below and try to get atop the leaderboard and to see how this tool works ;)

(If you can't see it, turn your images "ON")

*This is an affiliate link.

Need more newsletter support?

Here are a few ways I'd love to help you:

  1. Get clear on your newsletter strategy. ​
    Book a 1:1 Strategy Call With Me
    (30 mins || 1 Hour)
    ​
  2. Improving your newsletter engagement & reducing unsubscribes starts with how you onboard your new subscribers. Book a Newsletter Onboarding Audit >>​
    ​
  3. Get daily newsletter support in a private setting from myself, Chenell Basilio, and dozens of other newsletter creators.
    ​
    Join the Growth In Reverse Pro Community today >>​

See you in the inbox,

Dylan

​LinkedIn | Twitter | Substack | IG

* indicates affiliate links. I get paid a small commission if you use these links to purchase a product or service.

​.​

PS - While I was in Spain in September, I also took a 7-hour bus ride down to Lisbon. I was there for two full days and didn't know what to see or do, so I just put on my running shoes and ran around, racking up about 28kms over the two days. Some people do walking tours, I did a running tour! 🏃‍♂️💨


⚠️ Wanna PAUSE these emails instead of unsubscribing?

Hit the PAUSE button below and confirm on the next page.